At Kong Law, we ensure your case gets the second chance it deserves.
Appeals in NSW
When a court decision feels unjust or a sentence is too severe, an appeal provides the opportunity to challenge it. Courts hear appeals to review decisions made in errors of law, incorrect application of the law, or significant miscarriages of justice. In New South Wales, the appeal process is governed by strict legislation and tight time limits. Whether you’re appealing a conviction, a sentence, or both, it’s critical to act quickly and receive legal counsel early. Appeals are highly technical proceedings. They require a deep understanding of criminal procedure, evidentiary rules, and judicial reasoning. With Kong Law, you have a defence team that is highly experienced in advocating for clients in every jurisdiction.
Grounds for Criminal Appeals in NSW
Understanding the right grounds for appeal
Common grounds include: • Errors of law • Errors of fact • Miscarriage of justice or unfairness • Fresh or new evidence • Manifestly excessive or inadequate sentence
Criminal Appeals We Handle
Local Court Appeals to the District Court
An accused person who is convicted or sentenced in the Local Court may appeal to the District Court. A conviction appeal means the case is heard again from the start; a sentence appeal challenges only the penalty. Time limits are strict: appeals must usually be lodged within 28 days. The District Court can confirm, reduce, or overturn the outcome.
Appeals to the NSW Court of Criminal Appeal
Criminal matters from the District or Supreme Court can be appealed to the NSW Court of Criminal Appeal (CCA). The CCA reviews errors of law, unfairness, or sentences that are too harsh. It may uphold, vary, or overturn a decision, or order a new trial. It also hears appeals by the prosecution where a sentence is considered too lenient.
Judicial Review
If a Local Court has acted unfairly or beyond its powers, the Supreme Court of NSW can review the legality of the decision. Judicial review focuses on the lawfulness of the process, not whether the outcome was right or wrong.
High Court Appeals
The High Court of Australia hears only a small number of criminal appeals by special leave. These are granted only for matters of public importance or where justice requires it. High Court decisions are final.
Prosecution Appeals
The Director of Public Prosecutions may appeal if a sentence is clearly too low or legally flawed. These cases are rare and carefully limited to maintain fairness and finality. These appeals must demonstrate that the sentence is “manifestly inadequate” or contains an error in principle. Prosecution appeals are relatively infrequent and subject to strict standards, preserving the principle of finality in sentencing.
Frequently Asked Questions About Appeals
Frequently asked questions
Are appeals usually successful?
Success depends on the facts, the quality of preparation, and the skill of your appeal lawyer. Many appeals lead to reduced sentences or corrected errors.
Do you need a lawyer to make an appeal?
Yes. Appeals are complex, and having an experienced appeal lawyer ensures your documents, evidence, and submissions are handled correctly from the start.
What is the best way to win an appeal?
Work with a good appeal lawyer who can identify legal or factual errors in the original decision and present clear, well-prepared arguments to the court.
How long does the appeal process take?
It depends on the court. Local Court appeals are usually heard within a few weeks. Appeals to the Court of Criminal Appeal or High Court can take several months due to their complexity.
How long do I have to file an appeal in NSW?
You generally have 28 days from the date of your Local Court decision to lodge an appeal. Extensions are possible, but they’re not guaranteed, so it’s best to seek legal advice immediately.
