What counts as a breach
A breach is doing something the order prohibits: contacting the protected person, going to a prohibited address, or coming within a restricted distance. The conduct does not have to be a crime in itself. One text message, or being somewhere by coincidence, can be a breach if the conditions are worded strictly enough.
Breach charges commonly come from:
- calls, messages or social media contact, even when the protected person started it
- going to a shared address, workplace or venue covered by the order
- contact through a third party
- contact after an apparent reconciliation while a no-contact condition is still in place
Breach of AVO in NSW
In NSW, breaching an ADVO is an offence under the Crimes (Domestic and Personal Violence) Act 2007. The breach does not always need to be deliberate, but intent and awareness of the conditions are relevant to the defence. The hearing focuses on whether the conduct happened and whether it falls within what the order prohibits.
Breach of FVIO in Victoria
In Victoria, breaching an FVIO is an offence under the Family Violence Protection Act 2008. Courts treat it seriously, especially where the breach involved further threats, violence or a pattern of ignoring the conditions. As in NSW, the wording of the order decides whether a breach actually happened.
Penalties for breaching an order
The penalty can be a fine, imprisonment or both. The maximum and the likely outcome depend on the state, the nature of the breach, and whether there was violence or threats. Courts consider:
- whether the breach involved violence or threats, or was technical contact only
- whether it is a first breach or a pattern
- which conditions were breached and how clearly they were worded
- your criminal history and any earlier breaches
Second breach and persistent contravention
A second breach is treated more seriously than a first, and courts take a firmer approach once a pattern appears. In Victoria, a person who repeatedly breaches an order can be charged with persistent contravention, which is aimed at ongoing non-compliance rather than a single incident. Whether your matter is treated as a one-off or a pattern shapes the defence.
Defending a breach charge
The main questions are:
- whether the conditions were clear enough to be understood
- whether the contact was unintentional or coincidental
- whether the protected person's own conduct explains how it happened
Not every technical breach ends in a conviction, especially where the contact was minor, unintended or invited by the protected person. Courts treat the last point carefully, and it does not excuse a clear breach.
Related matters
A breach charge depends on the order behind it. See ADVOs for NSW orders, FVIOs for Victorian orders, and domestic violence charges for related criminal charges.
Frequently asked questions
Can I be charged with breaching an order if the other person contacted me first?
Yes. Contact from the protected person does not automatically excuse a breach, though it can matter to the defence.
What is the difference between breaching an AVO and breaching an FVIO?
Breach of AVO is a NSW offence and breach of FVIO is a Victorian one. Both are criminal offences separate from the order itself.
Will I go to prison for breaching a protection order?
That depends on whether the breach involved violence, what kind of breach it was, and whether it is your first or a repeated breach.
What happens if I accidentally breach an order?
Unintentional breaches can still be charged. Whether you intended it and knew the conditions are relevant to the defence.
