KONG LAW

Appeals

Appeal Against Sentence Lawyers NSW| Severity Appeals

Believe your sentence is too harsh given the circumstances of your matter? What’s called an appeal against sentence in everyday language is known in NSW practice as a severity appeal, challenging the penalty imposed as manifestly excessive, rather than challenging the finding of guilt itself. Our appeal sentence lawyers at Kong Law, as part of our broader Criminal Appeals practice and full criminal defence service, assess honestly whether your specific sentence genuinely meets this test.

Reviewed by Lingwei Kong, Criminal Defence Lawyer · Updated July 2026

This is distinct from an appeal against conviction, addressed on our separate page, and the two are sometimes argued together where both aspects of your matter are genuinely in dispute. Call Kong Law today for a confidential consultation.

What a Severity Appeal Actually Involves

Severity appeal NSW proceedings are governed by section 11 of the Crimes (Appeal and Review) Act 2001, the same provision covering conviction appeals, since both pathways sit within the same broader appeal mechanism. A sentence appeal lawyer needs to understand that this process doesn’t involve re-arguing whether you’re guilty, only whether the specific penalty imposed was manifestly excessive given the objective seriousness of the offence and your personal circumstances.

  • The Manifestly Excessive Test

    Manifestly excessive sentence appeal applications require demonstrating something significantly beyond simply believing a lighter sentence would have been fair. The test requires showing the sentence imposed was so far outside the range reasonably available to the original court that it reveals a genuine error, not merely that a different, more lenient outcome was arguably also open. This is a genuinely high bar, and courts are generally reluctant to interfere with a sentence simply because an appellate court might have reached a somewhat different figure itself.

  • Section 11 Severity Appeals to the District Court

    Section 11 severity appeal district court matters generally arise where a Local Court sentence is being appealed, proceeding to the District Court for a genuine rehearing rather than a limited review. Our District Court Appeals page explains this rehearing process, including how it applies both to conviction and severity appeals originating from the Local Court.

  • Crown Appeals Against Sentence

    Crown appeal against sentence matters work in the opposite direction to what most people expect. Rather than a person convicted appealing their own sentence as too harsh, a Crown appeal, brought by the prosecution, argues the sentence imposed was too lenient given the circumstances. DPP appeal sentence too lenient applications are less common than a standard severity appeal but genuinely significant, since they can result in an original sentence being increased on appeal, a real risk worth understanding if you're considering whether to challenge your own sentence and how the prosecution might separately respond.

Why This Differs From an Appeal Against Conviction

It’s worth being clear about this distinction, since the two are sometimes confused. An appeal against conviction challenges whether you were rightly found guilty at all. An appeal against sentence, or severity appeal, accepts the finding of guilt and challenges only the penalty imposed. Where you genuinely dispute both, this is addressed through an all grounds appeal, covered on our Appeal Against Conviction page, rather than two entirely separate processes.

  • How an Early Guilty Plea Affects a Sentence Appeal

    Because an early guilty plea generally attracts a meaningful sentencing discount, a severity appeal sometimes needs to grapple with whether that discount was properly applied in the first place, alongside the broader question of whether the resulting sentence was manifestly excessive. Our Sentencing and Plea Traversals pages explain how this discount works, and it's directly relevant background for understanding whether a genuine appeal ground exists in your matter.

  • Which Court Hears Your Sentence Appeal

    The specific court depends on where your original sentence was imposed, whether the Local Court, appealing to the District Court, or a more serious matter originally sentenced in the District or Supreme Court, appealing to the Court of Criminal Appeal. Our Local Court Appeals, District Court Appeals, and Court of Criminal Appeal pages explain these specific pathways.

How This Fits Within Criminal Appeals

Appeal against sentence sits within our broader Criminal Appeals practice, closely connected to Appeal Against Conviction given how often both are argued together, and to our Court Processes practice’s Sentencing and Plea Traversals pages, given how directly the original sentencing process and any guilty plea decision relate to whether a genuine appeal ground exists.

Frequently asked questions

What is a "severity appeal"?

It’s the NSW legal term for appealing a sentence, arguing the penalty imposed was manifestly excessive, as distinct from challenging the finding of guilt itself.

Is wanting a lighter sentence enough to succeed on appeal?

No. The sentence must be shown to be manifestly excessive, a genuinely high bar, not simply that a somewhat lighter sentence would also have been reasonable.

Can the prosecution appeal my sentence too?

Yes, through what’s called a Crown appeal, arguing your sentence was too lenient. This can result in your original sentence being increased on appeal.

Can I appeal my conviction and sentence together?

Yes, this is called an all grounds appeal, addressing both the finding of guilt and the penalty imposed in a single combined process.

Client Reviews

What clients say about Lingwei

5.0 / 5 · 10 Google reviews

Edward Liu

Mar 2026

Lingwei Kong, the Michael Jordan of the courtroom, he treated the courtroom like the NBA finals and dropped a legal 60 on them fools, absolute goat. Would hire again hopefully won’t need to though:)

Edward L

Mar 2026

Lingwei Kong aka The GOAT, helped me when nsw coppers pulled up with a whole cinematic universe of charges and this man deleted the entire storyline before the hearing even started. Cases dropped like it was Black Friday

Zhenliang Hu

Feb 2026

Mr LingWei Kong is a very patient solicitor who has been efficient and prompt in handling our case. He always acts in the best interests of his clients. Thank you.

Shin Tan

Feb 2026

It has been a great experience working with LingWei Kong Solicitor. He has been very prompt and clear in his communication, which has helped us maintain clear expectations, especially given the complexities of criminal law. He is very understanding and knowledgeable. Highly recommend!

A S

Feb 2026

I feel fortunate to have met Lawyer Kong, who boasts solid professional expertise and outstanding professional capabilities. He has always approached cases with a dedicated, rigorous and professional attitude. From the meticulous analysis in the early stages of the case to the professional guidance throughout the litigation process, Lawyer Kong provided me with comprehensive and tailored professional advice, patiently answered all my questions along the way, and offered me immense help and support. Thanks to his professional assistance and precise case management, my case finally achieved a successful judgment. Here, I would like to express my sincerest gratitude to Lawyer Kong from the bottom of my heart!

panpan Jin

Aug 2025

We are very grateful for Mr. Lingwei Kong’s professional service. He has solid legal knowledge and always acted in our best interest. Throughout the process, he provided clear guidance, protected our rights effectively, and made us feel fully supported. Highly recommend Mr Kong!

Joe Zhang

Aug 2025

Lawyer Lingwei Kong is patient, professional and efficient. Lawyer Kong is patient, professional and efficient. He helped me a lot.

Anon

Aug 2025

I had an excellent experience with Northan Criminal Law. Lingwei Kong was highly professional, knowledgeable, and thorough in handling my matter. He provided clear advice, guided me through each step of the process, and ensured I understood my options. His attention to detail and commitment gave me confidence throughout. I would strongly recommend Lingwei Kong to anyone looking for expert legal representation.

Joshua Adu-Dwumaa

Aug 2025

All I can say is Lingwei Kong is the man! I my experience with him was excellent. Despite stepping in at the last minute given very little prep time, he immediately put me at ease before court and handled everything with professionalism, confidence and showcased impressive knowledge and ability. He’s a top guy who is a pleasure to communicate with and thanks to his support, we achieved the result we were hoping for. I’m very happy with the outcome and truly appreciate the way he guided us through the process.

Victory C

Aug 2025

I had a great experience with Lingwei Kong while dealing with my case, and I truly appreciate the way he handled everything from start to finish. He was incredibly patient and took the time to explain each step clearly, making sure I understood things that were initially confusing to me. His ability to break down complex details into simple explanations gave me a lot of confidence and reassurance. What I valued most was how approachable and supportive he was. I never felt rushed, and he always listened carefully to my concerns. His professionalism, knowledge, and calm approach made the whole process much smoother and less overwhelming than I expected. I am very grateful for the time and effort that Lingwei Kong put into helping me. He went above and beyond to make sure I felt comfortable and informed throughout the entire experience. I would highly recommend him to anyone looking for someone reliable, patient, and genuinely dedicated to their clients.