Understanding the difference between wanting a different outcome and having a genuine legal basis to appeal a conviction matters enormously here, since an appeal isn’t simply a second chance to re-argue your case. Call Kong Law today for a confidential consultation.
What an Appeal Against Conviction Actually Involves
Conviction appeal lawyer work is governed by section 11 of the Crimes (Appeal and Review) Act 2001 (NSW), addressing the specific pathway for challenging a finding of guilt. This is distinct from a sentence appeal, which challenges the penalty rather than the finding of guilt itself, though the two can be argued together in what’s called an all grounds appeal where both aspects of your matter are genuinely in dispute.
Grounds to Appeal a Conviction
Grounds to appeal a conviction in NSW generally fall into several categories, and a genuine, identifiable basis is required rather than simply disagreeing with how the original decision was reached:
-
An error of law, where the court applied the wrong legal test or misdirected itself on a point of law.
-
Fresh evidence, genuinely new material that wasn't available at the time of the original hearing or trial.
-
A miscarriage of justice more broadly, where the process or outcome was fundamentally unfair in a way not captured by the two grounds above.
-
Error of Law
Error of law appeal conviction grounds address situations where the original court made a genuine mistake in how it applied or understood the relevant legal test, rather than simply reaching a factual conclusion you disagree with. This is a genuinely technical ground, requiring identification of a specific, identifiable legal error rather than a general sense that the outcome was wrong.
-
Fresh Evidence
Fresh evidence appeal applications require demonstrating that the new material genuinely wasn't available at the time of the original hearing, despite reasonable efforts to obtain it, and that it's sufficiently significant to potentially have affected the outcome. Simply finding additional supporting material after the fact doesn't automatically qualify if it could reasonably have been obtained and presented at the original hearing.
Miscarriage of Justice
Miscarriage of justice appeal grounds address situations where, even absent a specific identifiable error of law, the overall process or outcome was fundamentally unfair. This is a genuinely high bar, reserved for circumstances where the integrity of the original finding is seriously in question, not simply where a different outcome might have been preferable.
All Grounds Appeals
Where you believe both the conviction itself and the sentence imposed are open to challenge, this is addressed through an all grounds appeal, arguing both aspects together in a single process rather than pursuing separate appeals. Our Appeal Against Sentence page explains the specific grounds relevant to challenging a penalty, which can be raised alongside a conviction appeal where both genuinely apply to your matter.
Which Court Hears Your Appeal
The specific court hearing your conviction appeal depends on where your original matter was decided, whether the Local Court, appealing to the District Court, or a more serious indictable matter originally tried in the District or Supreme Court, appealing to the Court of Criminal Appeal. Our Local Court Appeals, District Court Appeals, and Court of Criminal Appeal pages explain these specific pathways in detail.
How This Fits Within Criminal Appeals
Appeal against conviction sits within our broader Criminal Appeals practice, closely connected to Appeal Against Sentence given how often both are argued together, and to the specific court level pages explaining exactly how and where your particular appeal needs to be lodged and heard.
Frequently asked questions
Can I appeal a conviction just because I disagree with the outcome?
No. A genuine legal ground, such as an error of law, fresh evidence, or a miscarriage of justice, is required, not simply dissatisfaction with how the matter was decided.
What counts as "fresh evidence"?
Genuinely new material that wasn’t available at the original hearing despite reasonable efforts to obtain it, and significant enough to potentially have affected the outcome.
What is an "error of law"?
This means the original court applied the wrong legal test or misdirected itself on a point of law, a specific and identifiable technical error rather than a factual disagreement.
Can I appeal my conviction and sentence at the same time?
Yes, this is called an all-grounds appeal, addressing both the finding of guilt and the penalty imposed together in a single appeal process.
