Two offences in one section
Section 18 of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) creates two offences: intentionally causing injury and recklessly causing injury. "Intentionally reckless injury" is not one combined charge. The two have different maximum penalties, and which one you face depends on what the prosecution believes it can prove about your intent.
Intentionally causing injury
The prosecution must prove you meant to cause the injury, not just that you meant to do the act. This is the more serious of the two, with a maximum penalty of 10 years' imprisonment.
These matters often turn on what was said before or during the incident, any earlier threats, and the act itself. A single deliberate blow is treated differently to an injury in a chaotic, fast-moving fight.
Recklessly causing injury
The prosecution does not have to prove you intended the injury, only that you were aware your conduct might possibly cause injury and went ahead anyway. That is easier to prove, so it is charged more often in fights, arguments that escalated and incidents involving alcohol. The maximum penalty is 5 years' imprisonment.
How the court decides which applies
The difference is your state of mind, not the injury. A broken nose from a single punch could be charged either way.
- If you meant to break that person's nose, that points to intentionally causing injury.
- If you threw the punch aware that injury might result but did not intend it, that points to recklessly causing injury.
- Earlier statements, the context of the incident and how the act was carried out all affect which charge the prosecution pursues.
A wrong assumption about which offence applies changes the whole defence, so the full brief needs to be reviewed early.
Maximum penalties and what courts consider
Intentionally causing injury carries up to 10 years' imprisonment and recklessly causing injury up to 5 years. Within those limits the court looks at:
- how serious the injury was and how long it lasted
- whether a weapon was used or shown
- your criminal history and personal circumstances
- remorse and the steps you have taken since the incident
- whether you pleaded guilty early
Causing injury charges in Melbourne
A causing injury charge anywhere in Victoria is dealt with under the same section 18.
How this fits with the other assault charges
These charges sit with common assault, assault occasioning actual bodily harm, grievous bodily harm and affray in our assault offences practice. The Victorian offences are assessed differently to their NSW equivalents, which matters if your matter, or a related one, crosses state lines.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between intentionally causing injury and recklessly causing injury?
Intentionally causing injury requires proof that you meant to cause the injury. Recklessly causing injury only requires proof that you were aware injury might occur and went ahead anyway.
What is the maximum penalty for intentionally causing injury in Victoria?
10 years' imprisonment.
What is the maximum penalty for recklessly causing injury in Victoria?
5 years' imprisonment.
Can the same incident be charged as either offence?
Yes. The same injury can support either charge. Which one is laid depends on what the evidence shows about your intent at the time.
Do these charges apply in NSW as well as Victoria?
No. Section 18 is Victorian law. In NSW, similar conduct is charged as assault occasioning actual bodily harm or grievous bodily harm.
