It is often charged alongside common assault or assault occasioning actual bodily harm from the same incident. Kong Law reviews the brief, including CCTV and body-worn footage, and tells you before your first court date what the prosecution has to prove and whether it can.
What is affray under NSW law
Affray is in section 93C of the Crimes Act 1900 (NSW). The prosecution must prove that you used or threatened unlawful violence towards another person, and that your conduct would have made a person of reasonable firmness at the scene fear for their safety.
- It can happen in a private place as well as a public one.
- Words alone are not enough. There must be violence or a threat of violence.
- No bystander has to actually be present. The test is how a reasonable person would have reacted if they were.
- Nobody has to be injured.
How affray differs from assault
Common assault, actual bodily harm and grievous bodily harm are about what was done to a particular person. Affray is about the effect of the conduct on anyone present. Police use it when they cannot say who did what to whom in a group fight, or add it to an assault charge when someone was hurt. You can be charged with both from the same event.
Group affray charges
When several people are charged from one incident, the evidence against each of them is different. What matters is what the footage and statements show you did, not what the group did.
Maximum penalty for affray
The maximum penalty is 10 years’ imprisonment. The court looks at:
- what you did, as opposed to the group as a whole
- whether a weapon was used or shown
- where it happened and how big the disturbance was
- any injuries that resulted, even if charged separately
- your record and personal circumstances
Defences to affray
The most common issue is identification. Group incidents are chaotic, and police and witnesses often get wrong who did what. Self-defence applies if your conduct was a reasonable response to a threat you believed you faced. Sometimes the argument is that your own conduct, looked at by itself, would not have frightened a reasonable bystander, and that you were only present at a chaotic scene.
Affray and bail
Bail conditions are often set on the night of the charge. They may stop you contacting co-accused or going to certain venues. Raise them with a lawyer straight away, because the court needs a reason to change them later.
Affray as a first offence
A first affray charge does not usually lead to prison when your part was limited and nobody was hurt by your own conduct.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between affray and assault?
Assault is about what was done to a particular person. Affray is about whether the conduct would have frightened a reasonable bystander at the scene.
Can I be charged with affray and assault from the same incident?
Yes. Police often charge affray together with common assault or assault occasioning actual bodily harm when someone was injured in the same incident.
What is the maximum penalty for affray in NSW?
10 years’ imprisonment.
Do I need to have hit someone to be charged with affray?
No. A threat of violence is enough if it would make a reasonable bystander fear for their safety. Words alone are not.
Will I get bail if charged with affray?
That depends on your record and the allegations. Bail often comes with conditions such as not contacting co-accused or staying away from a venue. Those conditions are easiest to challenge at the first court date.
