Unlike a Local Court hearing decided by a magistrate alone, a criminal trial often involves a jury determining guilt based on evidence presented by both the prosecution and defence. We explain exactly what your specific trial process will involve and prepare your defence accordingly. Call Kong Law today for a confidential consultation.
Define Criminal Trial, and How It Differs From a Hearing
To define criminal trial simply: it’s the formal court process where a person charged with a serious indictable offence has the charge determined, generally by a jury, based on evidence presented by both sides. This differs significantly from a Local Court hearing, addressed on our separate Court Hearings page, where a magistrate alone decides the outcome for less serious matters. Criminal trial examples typically include serious matters such as more serious assault charges, sexual offences, or serious drug supply matters, rather than summary offences dealt with entirely in the Local Court.
The Criminal Trial Process Step by Step
The step-by-step criminal trial process generally follows this sequence:
-
Committal, where the Local Court determines whether there's sufficient evidence for the matter to proceed to a higher court.
-
Arraignment in the higher court, where the charge is formally read and a plea entered.
-
Criminal trial jury selection, where a jury is empanelled from the community to hear the matter.
-
The trial itself, involving opening addresses, presentation of evidence in a criminal trial from both prosecution and defence, cross-examination of witnesses, and closing addresses.
-
Jury deliberation and verdict, followed by sentencing if a guilty verdict is returned or a guilty plea was entered.
-
Criminal Trial Jury Selection
Criminal jury trial process considerations begin with jury selection, where a panel is drawn from the community and both the prosecution and defence have limited ability to challenge specific jurors before the jury is finalised. Understanding this process, and what genuinely influences it, is one part of proper trial preparation, though it's only the starting point of a much longer process.
-
Evidence and Defendants' Rights
Evidence in a criminal trial must generally be properly admissible, and both sides can challenge the admissibility of specific evidence before or during the trial itself. Defendants' rights in a criminal trial include the right to be presumed innocent until proven guilty, the right to legal representation, and the right to have the prosecution prove its case beyond reasonable doubt, a genuinely high standard central to the entire trial process.
Criminal Trial Proceedings in Practice
Criminal trial proceedings can extend over days or weeks depending on the complexity of the matter, the number of witnesses involved, and the volume of evidence presented. A criminal trial procedure that appears straightforward on paper can become genuinely complex once specific evidentiary disputes arise, which is why thorough preparation well before the trial date matters enormously, not just preparation once the trial has actually begun.
Federal Criminal Trials
A federal criminal trial follows a broadly similar process to a state trial but proceeds under Commonwealth jurisdiction, relevant to matters such as certain drug importation charges or specific white collar offences prosecuted by the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions rather than NSW authorities. Understanding whether your matter is a state or Commonwealth trial affects the specific court, procedure, and prosecuting body involved, which is why this distinction matters from the earliest stages of preparation.
How This Fits Within Court Processes
Criminal trials sit within our broader Court Processes practice, following on from a committal process where a matter has been found to have sufficient evidence to proceed from the Local Court. Where a trial results in a conviction you believe was wrongly decided, or a sentence you consider unjust, our Criminal Appeals practice addresses those next steps.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a hearing and a criminal trial?
A hearing is decided by a magistrate alone in the Local Court. A criminal trial takes place in a higher court and often involves a jury determining the outcome.
Do all serious charges automatically go to trial?
Not necessarily. Many matters resolve through a guilty plea before trial, with a trial only occurring where a not guilty plea is maintained through to that stage.
What happens during jury selection?
A jury panel is drawn from the community, with both the prosecution and defence having limited ability to challenge specific jurors before the jury is finalised.
What standard of proof applies in a criminal trial?
The prosecution must prove the case beyond reasonable doubt, a high standard reflecting the presumption of innocence that applies throughout the trial process.
