Whether your matter involves a contested hearing in the Local Court or a preliminary step before a more serious matter proceeds further, we explain exactly what type of hearing you’re facing and what genuinely needs to be prepared. Call Kong Law today for a confidential consultation.
What Distinguishes a Hearing From a Mention
The criminal court hearing process differs significantly from the mention or call over stage most people encounter first. Where a mention is largely procedural, a hearing involves the actual substance of your matter being argued, whether that’s a contested Local Court matter where you’ve pleaded not guilty, or a preliminary hearing addressing a specific procedural issue before the matter progresses further.
Types of Hearings in Criminal Court
Types of hearings in criminal court vary depending on the stage and nature of your matter. These generally include:
-
A contested hearing in a criminal matter, where you've pleaded not guilty to a summary offence, and the Local Court determines the outcome based on evidence.
-
A directions hearing criminal proceeding, addressing procedural matters such as timetabling or what evidence will be relied on, rather than determining guilt itself.
-
A discovery hearing in a criminal court matter, addressing what evidence or material needs to be disclosed between the prosecution and defence.
-
A review hearing in criminal court, checking on the progress of a matter, particularly relevant for more complex cases still being prepared.
-
Preliminary and Pre-Trial Hearings
Court preliminary hearing matters, and criminal preliminary hearing steps more broadly, generally address procedural or evidentiary questions before a matter is ready to proceed to its substantive hearing or trial. A pretrial hearing in a criminal case can address issues such as whether certain evidence will be admissible, without determining the ultimate outcome of your matter at that stage. Understanding the preliminary hearing process, and what's actually being decided at each specific step, helps you know what to genuinely expect rather than assuming every hearing determines your case's final outcome.
-
The Contested Hearing Itself
A contested hearing in a criminal matter in the Local Court generally involves the prosecution presenting its evidence first, including calling witnesses who may be cross-examined, followed by an opportunity for the defence to present evidence or make submissions. The magistrate then determines the outcome based on the evidence presented. Preparation for this stage is significantly more involved than for a mention, since the actual substance of your matter is being tested here.
-
Review Hearings
A review hearing in a criminal case generally checks on the progress of a more complex matter, ensuring it remains on track toward its next substantive step, whether that's a further hearing, a committal, or a trial in a higher court. These appearances are typically brief and procedural in nature, similar to a mention, but they occur within the context of a matter already identified as requiring a contested hearing or further steps.
-
How This Differs From a Criminal Trial
It's worth being clear about an important distinction. A Local Court hearing, including a contested hearing, is heard and determined by a magistrate alone. A criminal trial, addressed on our separate Criminal Trials page, generally takes place in a higher court and, for more serious matters, can involve a jury. Understanding which pathway applies to your specific matter, Local Court hearing or higher court trial, depends on the classification of your offence.
How This Fits Within Court Processes
Court hearings sit within our broader Court Processes practice, following on from your initial mention where you’ve indicated a not guilty plea to a matter suitable for the Local Court. Where your matter is more serious and proceeds toward a higher court instead, our Criminal Trials page explains that separate pathway.
Frequently Asked Questions About Hearings
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a mention and a hearing?
A mention is a brief, procedural first appearance. A hearing involves evidence actually being presented and tested, often including witnesses being cross-examined.
What happens at a directions hearing?
This addresses procedural matters, such as timetabling or what evidence will be relied on, rather than determining the outcome of your matter itself.
Is a preliminary hearing the same as my final hearing?
Not usually. A preliminary hearing generally addresses a specific procedural or evidentiary question before your matter is ready for its substantive hearing.
Who decides the outcome of a Local Court hearing?
A magistrate decides, sitting alone, based on the evidence presented by both the prosecution and defence during the contested hearing.
Do I need a lawyer for my first appearance?
Yes. Early advice prevents mistakes that could affect your case later.
Can my lawyer appear for me?
In many Local Court mentions, yes. For defended hearings or sentencing, you’ll usually need to attend.
What if I miss my hearing?
A warrant can be issued for your arrest. Always notify your lawyer if you can’t attend.
How long do hearings take?
It depends on the case. Simple matters may finish in one day, while defended hearings or trials can run over several days.
Can I appeal the outcome?
Yes. If you believe the sentence or conviction was unfair, your lawyer can appeal to the District Court for a fresh hearing.
