The right to appeal in criminal cases exists, but it isn’t unlimited, and the appeal period in criminal cases is often genuinely strict, sometimes as short as 28 days. Whether you need an urgent criminal appeal lawyer immediately after a decision, or want to understand your options calmly before deciding, call Kong Law today for a confidential consultation.
Why the Right Appellate Lawyer Matters
An appellate lawyer needs experience genuinely distinct from trial or hearing work, since appeal process criminal case matters focus on identifying specific legal or factual errors in a prior decision, not re-arguing the whole case from scratch. Criminal appeal procedure differs meaningfully depending on which court your matter is appealing from and which court is receiving it. Our criminal appellate lawyer team assesses:
- Which court your original decision came from, since this determines the correct appeal pathway and receiving court.
- Whether you're appealing the conviction itself, the sentence, or both together, known as an all grounds appeal.
- What the applicable deadline is for your specific type of appeal, since these vary and some are genuinely unforgiving.
- Whether genuine grounds exist, since an appeal requires an identifiable error, not simply dissatisfaction with the outcome.
Types of Appeals in Criminal Cases
Types of appeals in criminal cases generally fall into two categories: a conviction appeal, challenging the finding of guilt itself, and a sentence appeal, known in NSW practice as a severity appeal, challenging the penalty as manifestly excessive. Where both are argued together, this is called an all grounds appeal.
-
Appeal Against Conviction
Appeal against conviction addresses situations where you believe the finding of guilt itself was wrong, whether due to an error of law, fresh evidence that wasn't available at trial, or a genuine miscarriage of justice. Our Appeal Against Conviction page explains the specific grounds required and how this process works.
-
Appeal Against Sentence
An appeal against sentence, known as a severity appeal in NSW, addresses situations where the penalty imposed is argued to be manifestly excessive given the circumstances. Our Appeal Against Sentence page explains this process, including how it differs from challenging the conviction itself.
-
Local Court Appeals
Local Court appeals address the most common appeal pathway in NSW, where a Local Court decision, conviction or sentence is appealed to the District Court. Our Local Court Appeals page explains this process and its strict filing deadline.
District Court Appeals
District Court appeals address the District Court’s role as the receiving court for appeals from the Local Court, generally involving a genuine rehearing of the original evidence rather than a limited review. Our District Court Appeals page explains this rehearing process.
Court of Criminal Appeal
Court of Criminal Appeal judgments come from the CCA, part of the Supreme Court, hearing appeals from more serious indictable trials originally heard in the District or Supreme Court, typically before a three-judge panel. Our Court of Criminal Appeal page explains this significantly higher-stakes tier.
-
High Court Appeals
Appeal to the High Court in criminal cases represents the final and most limited avenue available, requiring special leave that's granted only for matters of genuine public importance. Our High Court Appeals page explains this process and why it's rarely a realistic pathway for most matters.
-
Post-Conviction Process More Broadly
Post-conviction process considerations extend beyond formal appeals alone, and can sometimes involve related pathways depending on your specific circumstances. Understanding the full range of options realistically available to you, not just the appeal pathway itself, is something we assess honestly at your first consultation.
Where We Practise
Our criminal appeal lawyers in Sydney, alongside the appeal barristers we brief, appear across every relevant court level, from Local Court appeals up to High Court special leave applications, understanding the genuinely different skills each tier demands.
Appeals: related pages
Frequently asked questions
How long do I have to appeal a criminal decision in NSW?
This depends on the specific type of appeal and court level, but deadlines are often strict, sometimes as short as 28 days, so acting quickly matters significantly.
What is the difference between appealing a conviction and appealing a sentence?
A conviction appeal challenges the finding of guilt itself. A sentence appeal, called a severity appeal in NSW, challenges the penalty as manifestly excessive.
Can I appeal both my conviction and sentence together?
Yes, this is called an all grounds appeal, addressing both the finding of guilt and the penalty imposed in a single appeal process.
Is an appeal a chance to re-argue my whole case?
Not quite. An appeal generally focuses on identifying a specific legal or factual error in the original decision, rather than simply re-arguing the matter from scratch.
What is the highest level of criminal appeal available in Australia?
The High Court of Australia, though this requires special leave, granted only for matters of genuine public importance, making it a genuinely limited pathway.
