Blackmail under NSW law
Blackmail is in section 249K of the Crimes Act 1900 (NSW), in Part 4B. The test is an unwarranted demand with menaces: a demand backed by a threat, where the person has no legal right to what they are demanding, or knows the threat is not a proper way to pursue a legitimate claim.
What the prosecution must prove
- a demand was made
- it came with a threat or menace
- the demand was unwarranted
The demand does not have to be for money. It can be for any gain, or aimed at causing someone a loss. The menace does not have to be physical. Threats to a person's reputation or property count.
Sextortion
Sextortion usually involves a threat to share intimate images or information unless the person pays money or sends more images. It is prosecuted as blackmail, because the test is the same whatever the threat is. These matters mostly happen online. Where images were threatened to be shared, intimate image offences may also be charged.
Aggravated blackmail
Blackmail is aggravated when the demand involves accusing someone, truthfully or falsely, of a serious indictable offence. It is treated as a more serious form of the offence.
How blackmail differs from robbery
Robbery, under sections 94 and 95 of the Crimes Act, is force or a threat of force used at the time to take property on the spot. Blackmail is a threat about the future: do this, or this will happen. Whether the threat was immediate or conditional decides which offence applies and how it is defended.
Penalties and sentencing
The court looks at:
- what was demanded and what was threatened
- whether the charge is the basic or aggravated offence
- how vulnerable the person threatened was
- whether any harm or loss resulted
- how sophisticated the scheme was, for example a sextortion operation with several victims
Related offences
Robbery is dealt with under property and theft offences because it involves immediate force. Where a blackmail matter also involves threatened sharing of intimate images, we deal with both charges together.
Frequently asked questions
Is blackmail the same as extortion in NSW?
Yes. Blackmail is the legal term in NSW. Extortion is the everyday word for the same conduct.
Does the demand have to be for money?
No. It can be for any gain, or aimed at causing a loss. The menace can be a threat to safety, reputation or property.
Is sextortion a separate offence to blackmail?
No. Sextortion is prosecuted as blackmail. The test is the same whatever the threat is.
What makes a blackmail charge aggravated?
The demand involves accusing someone, truthfully or falsely, of a serious indictable offence.
